How to Build a World-Class Customer Service Team In 2025

Investing in your customer service team isn't about minimizing churn after issues arise — it's about maximizing customer lifetime value (CLV) by proactively creating exceptional experiences.

Let’s get into why.

Understanding the Impact of Customer Service on Loyalty and Retention

Customer loyalty isn’t built on product quality alone. It’s forged in the everyday interactions customers have with your brand, especially when things go wrong.

According to PwC's Future of Customer Experience report, 32% of customers would stop buying from a previously-loved brand after one bad experience.

Meanwhile, Salesforce Research found that 88% of consumers are more likely to make another purchase after a positive customer service experience. And 75% of respondents stated that they had recommended a company based on great customer service.

In SaaS, where subscription revenue depends on renewals, this loyalty gap isn’t just a customer satisfaction metric — it’s a survival metric.

The reality: Every positive customer service interaction reinforces trust and increases stickiness. Every negative one erodes the foundation you’ve worked hard (and spent heavily) to build.

The Financial Upside of Excellent Customer Service

Exceptional customer service isn’t just good for customer sentiment — it’s a direct driver of financial outcomes.

When customer service is exceptional:

• Higher retention reduces acquisition costs (it’s 5–25x more expensive to acquire a new customer than to retain an existing one, according to Bain & Company).
• Repeat purchases by happy customers add to your bottom line. Harvard Business Review found that customers who had the best past experiences spend 140% more compared to those who had the poorest experiences.
• Greater upsells and cross-sells drive up your average contract value (ACV).
• Increased referrals power organic growth without proportional marketing spend.

In other words, customer service isn’t always a cost center. When managed strategically, it can be a profit center.

Assessing Your Customer Service Team’s Performance

Building a customer service team is one thing. Building an exceptional one — the kind that retains customers, earns referrals, and fuels growth — is another entirely.

In today's hyper-competitive markets, having an "adequate" team isn't enough. "Adequate" means you’re stuck somewhere in the middle on the customer satisfaction scale. This is the realm where people will say your customer service is just meh. To sum it up: Adequate teams keep you afloat. Exceptional teams drive you forward.

If you want to really move the needle, you need to provide your customers with excellent customer service that not only fulfills your customers’ expectations but also surpasses them.

The juice is worth the squeeze! If you can pull this off, you can count on getting more customers through word of mouth (almost 60% of surveyees said so) and making more money (according to the cited report, as much as 72% of shoppers are willing to spend more money with a brand if they are amazed by the quality of its CS).

The benefits don’t end here. Your company as a whole profits, too. Positive customer feedback is a great motivator for the team, and companies known for good customer service are usually more stable and grow even in difficult market conditions. This happens because people don’t give up easily on good service, especially concerning products and services they need or value.

From Adequate to Exceptional: Key Differentiators

What makes a customer service team exceptional? That’s the million-dollar question.

Adequate customer service hits the minimum expectations.
Exceptional customer service creates moments that customers remember — and talk about.

Here's how the two stack up:

	Adequate CS Team	Exceptional CS Team
Communication Channels	Offers 1-2 basic options (e.g., phone or email only)	Delivers true omnichannel support - chat, email, phone calls, social media, messaging apps, etc
Customer Retention Focus	Low emphasis on loyalty and proactive support	High focus on customer satisfaction, loyalty building, and LTV growth
Onboarding Experience	Long, confusing, inflexible onboarding	Fast, intuitive onboarding with customization and self-service options
Response Time	Delayed responses (24-48 hours)	Fast, context-aware responses. Often instant with live chat or chatbots
Continuous Improvement	Minimal training, reactive upskilling	Ongoing training on customer engagement, empathy, and advanced tools

Real World Examples

• Intercom’s Resolution Bot helps businesses automatically resolve 33% of common customer questions, accelerating first response times and freeing up agents for complex customer issues.
• At Zappos, legendary for its customer obsession, agents are trained to prioritize customer happiness over call quotas — even if it means spending hours solving a single customer’s needs.
  

Great customer service teams aren’t just more efficient — they’re deeply aligned with the customer’s success and the company’s growth goals.

Real-World Scenarios: Adequate vs. Great Customer Service Responses

To show you this difference in practice, let’s analyze five common scenarios and see how adequate and great customer service teams would handle them.

SCENARIO 1: A QUESTION ABOUT THE PRODUCT

A customer wants to get in touch with your customer service to ask about one of the product’s features.

An adequate customer service team replies with the answer after a day or two. They may even send an automatic reply about processing the inquiry. This is not bad, but it could be better.

The great customer service team not only tries to answer the question as quickly as possible but also offers additional support, e.g., access to an extensive knowledge base. Most likely, there is also a 24/7 chatbot capable of answering the most common questions immediately.

Example: Help Scout’s Docs tool empowers teams to deliver instant answers via self-serve content, cutting ticket volumes by 20–30% while enhancing customer satisfaction.

SCENARIO 2: A REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL

In the B2B world, RFPs are very common.

An adequate team would simply prepare a templated proposal for the potential client along with one or two pricing options, and they will likely make some assumptions to speed up the process. And while the desire to get back to the prospect as quickly as possible is commendable, it should never be at the price of a low-quality response.

A great customer service team would also try to be quick, but more importantly, they would ask additional questions to understand the given customer’s needs. They would ensure that they send a proposal that ticks all the potential client’s boxes. They might even ask for a few days to get back to the prospect with an offer so that the person on the other side of the screen knows what to expect.

Example: HubSpot emphasizes that close alignment between sales and service teams drives a more customer-centric approach, improving deal velocity and long-term satisfaction.

SCENARIO 3: A PROBLEM WITH THE SERVICE

Suppose one of your customers has a technical issue, and they want to troubleshoot it with your customer service.

An adequate team will just send or read out a list of three or four possible solutions and ask the customer to try all of them.

We admit it, sometimes you don’t need to do anything else, but a great team will always first check whether everything works correctly on their end. They won’t assume that the problem is typical or that it’s the customer’s fault. A consultant will stay on the line or at the chatbox to ensure the customer has solved their problem and the service is back on again.

Example: Freshworks trains service teams to prioritize fast, personalized resolution rather than handoffs, reducing customer effort and boosting satisfaction.

Unlock the CX Vault

We’ve collected the goods — AI prompts, exclusive deals, and a library of secrets from CX leaders. Now unlock your free account to get ‘em.

Email*

By signing up, you agree to receive occasional emails. You can unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Phone

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

SCENARIO 4: VISITING THE WEBSITE

Many customers go to your website first before they get in touch with your company. What can they find on it? Even in 2022, some companies offer merely adequate experience, with many web pages being vague or lacking crucial content—this can be maddening for customers.

You can turn a website visit into a great experience by creating a blog section with helpful and practical posts, providing an extensive knowledge base or help section with FAQs, and offering several different forms of contact with your company. This preventative approach also reduces the amount of inbound inquiries your CS team has to deal with and sets them up for success.

Example: Gorgias helps e-commerce brands unify CX across web, chat, and social to offer seamless customer journeys — improving CSAT and reducing tickets.

SCENARIO 5: THE ONBOARDING PROCESS

In B2B, cooperation frequently starts with the onboarding of a new user.

An adequate customer service team will just offer one form of this process without the possibility (or willingness) to adjust it for a given company’s specificity or needs. You’ve been there, haven’t you? How many times have you tried to ask for a custom-made solution, and there was no such option?

In a great customer service team, things work a bit differently. Of course, some elements are fixed and automated, but customer service agents have the power to make reasonable adjustments if the situation requires it. They follow the true problem-solving, client-centric approach. And if something cannot be done, they offer alternatives or at least a viable explanation.

Example: Asana’s customer onboarding includes industry-specific templates, proactive webinars, and onboarding specialists to fast-track time to value.

After reading these five scenarios, ask yourself this one question: Is your team delivering adequate service — or the kind of standout experiences that customers rave about?

Recognizing the difference is the first step toward building a service culture that drives sustainable growth. And the first step on that path? It all starts with the people.

Hiring For Customer Service: The Foundation of a Stellar Team

If you are a customer service manager, you are likely responsible for recruiting the best candidates for your contact center.

Behind every standout customer experience is a strategically built customer service team — one hired not just for technical skills, but for empathy, resilience, and proactive problem-solving.

Your objective is to find candidates that are willing to learn new customer service skills and up their game.

There are two main sources of information about each and every candidate - their resumes and their answers and statements during the job interview. Let’s start with the latter.

Hiring for Excellence: Interview Questions That Reveal True Potential

When you're hiring for your customer service team, you're not just filling seats.
You're selecting the future stewards of your brand’s reputation.

Resume bullet points can tell you what someone has done. Smart interview questions reveal who they really are.

Here are five targeted questions that top companies use to screen for real customer-first thinkers:

Interview Question	What It Reveals
"What is the best customer service you've ever received? Why?"	Whether they recognize and value great service
"Have you ever dealt with an unreasonable customer? How did you handle it?"	Emotional resilience and conflict management skills
"Have you ever received negative feedback from a customer? What did you do?"	Growth mindset and accountability
"How would you help a customer who's frustrated after dealing with multiple agents?"	Empathy, ownership, and problem-solving under pressure
"Have you ever bent the rules to help a customer? What happened?"	Judgment, creativity, and risk assessment

Learn from Experts

• Zappos famously interviews for cultural fit first — prioritizing kindness, adaptability, and customer obsession over technical credentials.
• At Shopify, recruiters emphasize hiring people who are comfortable with ambiguity and rapid learning, essential traits when serving fast-moving SaaS businesses.

Key takeaway: Hire for the hard-to-train traits first. In customer service, you can train product knowledge. You can’t easily train empathy, initiative, or resilience.

Recognizing and Interpreting Resume Red Flags

When analyzing resumes, you will come across things that will make you wonder about the given person’s commitment, performance, or reliability. The best time for these red flags to come up is during the screening process. Otherwise you might, for example, hire a person who will drag the whole CS team down and decrease its morale.

Take a look at some typical red flags you need to pay attention to:

• Lengthy unemployment gaps (potential problems with landing a job? Why?)
• Unusual employment history (multiple shifts in career can indicate that the candidate still doesn’t have a plan for themselves)
• Job hopping (multiple jobs over a short period—it’s rarely a good sign if the candidate has trouble staying put for more than a few months)
• Errors of all kinds (they suggest a lack of attention to detail, which is crucial in working with customers)
• Demotion (if the candidate was a CS manager and ended up as a consultant, there must have been a reason)

In my experience, red flags aren't always deal-breakers. Instead, treat them like conversation starters. You may find stories of surprising resilience hidden behind career pivots or employment breaks.

Pro Tip: Look for patterns over anomalies. One typo or gap might not matter, but repeated signs of instability or sloppiness could foreshadow future performance risks.

Advanced Strategies for customer service development

Once you’ve built a customer service team, you should continually work on developing and upgrading each consultant’s skill set. Continuous improvement isn't a luxury in CX. It's a survival strategy.

To deliver consistently better experiences, you need structured, strategic team development programs built around feedback, journey optimization, and skill growth.

Leveraging Customer Feedback for Continuous Improvement

It all starts with what your customers really think about communicating with your company. Customer feedback isn't just an evaluation tool — it's your ongoing blueprint for service excellence.

According to Salesforce's State of Service report, 66% expect companies to adapt to their changing needs. A report by Aberdeen Group showed that companies that act on VoC analytics see a 14.5% increase in CSAT in less than a year.

So how do you gather feedback? Leading companies use feedback collection tools and approach feedback through three key strategies:

1. Closed-Loop Feedback

Instead of letting negative survey results collect dust, top teams actively follow up with dissatisfied customers.

For example, Zendesk users can build automations that trigger alerts whenever a low CSAT or NPS score is submitted. Agents can then be empowered to close the loop — reaching out personally to resolve the issue and deepen the customer relationship before it's too late.

You should conduct at least one customer survey (see how to measure customer experience and track top customer service metrics) and thoroughly analyze the received feedback. Pinpoint all the problems and shortcomings that your customers noticed; it’s a good starting point. Needless to say, these surveys ought to be conducted regularly.

2. Voice of Customer (VoC) Programs

Beyond surveys alone, companies like JetBlue unify feedback across technical support tickets, reviews, and social media to build a complete picture of the customer experience.
Using platforms like Qualtrics, these brands aggregate VoC data into actionable insights, guiding everything from service training priorities to product roadmap updates.

3. Predictive Feedback Analytics

Waiting for survey responses is reactive. Leaders now predict dissatisfaction before formal complaints arise.

With tools like Medallia, companies monitor sentiment changes in customer interactions, allowing them to proactively coach agents, tweak processes, and intervene before a churn decision happens.

Streamlining the Customer Journey to Enhance Service Delivery

The longer and clunkier the customer journey, the harder it becomes to deliver great service at scale. Modern customer journeys demand speed, personalization, and minimal friction. Every extra click, form, or login hurdle adds hidden churn risk, so it's crucial to constant optimize customer journeys, especially in B2B.

Research from Gartner shows that 96% of customers who experience high-effort service interactions become disloyal, compared to just 9% who experience low-effort interactions.

Areas to streamline immediately:

Problem	Friction It Creates	How To Fix It
Too many IVR phone options	Confuses and frustrates callers	Implement smart IVR that understands intent faster
Forced account creation before service	Increases abandonment rates	Offer guest checkout or streamlined sign-up options
Paper-based onboarding or contracts	Slows time-to-value, increases drop-off	Adopt digital signatures (DocuSign, PandaDoc)
Multiple portal logins	Exhausts customers trying to complete simple tasks	Consolidate logins via SSO (Single Sign-On) solutions

Case Study

Amazon’s introduction of the "Buy Now" button is a classic example of frictionless CX — significantly improving checkout speed and customer satisfaction by reducing steps in the purchasing journey.

Upskilling Your Customer Service Representatives

Hiring great people is only the start. If you want a team that continually delivers standout customer experiences, skill development has to be a permanent, intentional strategy — not a one-off training event.

Continuous upskilling not only improves customer satisfaction — it boosts employee retention, morale, and career growth.

Creating a Tailored Skill Development Program

In customer service, soft skills and communication skills are essential, and you, as a manager, have to invest in them. According to Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace 2023 Report, companies with highly engaged employees achieve 23% higher profitability and 18% higher customer loyalty compared to those with low engagement

Create a personalized, strategic skill development program for customer service representative in your company. This will enable them to expand their knowledge on how to work with customers and assist them in solving their problems. When working on it, pay attention to these five steps:

1. Conduct a TNA (Training Needs Analysis): Understand current competencies, gaps, and future service demands.
2. Identify crucial focus areas and goals: Focus on empathy, conflict resolution, multi-channel communication, problem-solving, and customer service technology fluency.
3. Curate optimal learning paths: Mix live workshops, self-paced e-learning, peer coaching, and hands-on projects.
4. Engage employees in designing their skill development pathways: When reps co-own their growth plans, motivation and outcomes both improve.
5. Track, measure, and iterate: Set clear KPIs (e.g., CSAT lift, first-contact resolution rates) and refine programs based on real-world performance.

Key resource: When preparing for evaluations, having a list of customer service performance review phrases is invaluable.

If you're building a formal training program, it helps to tap into industry-recognized certifications and courses. We’ve rounded up some excellent customer success certification options, as well as courses in customer service and customer success. These include the Certified Customer Success Manager (CCSM) program from SuccessCOACHING, the Customer Success Foundations course from Aspireship, and a course on Managing Customer Expectations by Dale Carnegie.

The Role of Mentorship and Internal Growth Opportunities

Training alone isn’t enough. Mentorship and career pathways turn decent service teams into exceptional ones.

Why mentorship matters:

• It accelerates skill mastery by pairing newer reps with seasoned high performers.
• It reduces turnover by creating visible paths for internal mobility.
• It builds a collaborative, resilient service culture where learning never stops.

Why internal growth opportunities matter:

Career growth locks in loyalty. If your best customer service agents can't see a clear path upward, they’ll eventually seek it elsewhere.

Offering transparent promotion tracks — such as Specialist → Senior Specialist → Team Lead → Manager — keeps top performers motivated and deeply invested in the company’s success.

For instance, at American Express, internal career mobility is a strategic pillar within the Customer Care organization. Frontline service professionals are actively encouraged to move into leadership, training, and operational roles. This helps the financial institution retain top talent while strengthening their customer-first culture.

How to Build a Mentorship And Growth Framework That Works:

• Formalize mentorship programs — define mentor/mentee goals, timelines, and success metrics.
• Clarify internal career ladders — show employees what advancement looks like and how to get there.
• Celebrate internal promotions publicly — make career success stories visible and aspirational.
• Track outcomes — measure improvements in employee satisfaction, engagement, and retention tied to development initiatives.

At Zappos, every new hire undergoes intensive culture training and is paired with mentors to deeply ingrain customer-first thinking from day one

Cultivating a Positive Work Environment for Service Teams

Great customer experiences don’t just happen because of training manuals or KPIs.
They happen because your service team feels safe, valued, and set up for success.

Building a positive work environment is a force multiplier — boosting morale, improving retention, and ultimately enhancing every customer interaction.

The Link Between Employee Satisfaction and Customer Experience

There's a direct, measurable connection between how your employees feel and how your customers feel. According to Gallup, engaged employees produce 23% higher profitability and 18% higher customer loyalty.

When employees feel supported, they:

• Communicate with more authenticity and empathy
• Solve problems faster and more creatively
• Stay longer, reducing costly turnover and knowledge loss

Key ways to cultivate satisfaction inside service teams:

• Foster psychological safety — where reps feel safe raising ideas, questions, and concerns without fear of blame.
• Recognize achievements frequently and authentically — not just with awards, but with real appreciation tied to company values.
• Support career development and internal mobility, not just task mastery.

Bottom line: Happy employees create happy customers — and both are essential for sustainable growth.

Case Study: At Southwest Airlines, front-line teams are trusted to take ownership of customer interactions, applying personal judgment rather than following rigid scripts — a hallmark of their customer service success.

Setting Clear, Achievable Expectations for Your Team

Customer support agents should never wonder what they are expected to do or how to communicate with customers. Provide them with clear, reasonable (that’s a keyword; forget about unrealistic KPIs and requirements) expectations that are easily accessible and verifiable.

When people know what they are expected to do, they are more engaged in their role and feel psychological comfort, which is key to unlocking any person’s best work. Ambiguity breeds stress. And stressed teams rarely deliver consistently great customer experiences.

Clear expectation setting is also important if you opt to outsource your customer service to a third-party provider. Being on the same page is essential when you're engaging an external team to provide services to your customer base. To do that, start with a list of the pros and cons and CX impacts of outsourcing customer service. Then get to know the company's ethos, approach, and values. And likewise, take time to share your own and set clear expectations around how you'd like their agents to represent your business.

What clear expectations look like:

• Defined KPIs: Metrics like First Response Time (FRT), Customer Satisfaction (CSAT), and Resolution Time are clearly set, monitored, and coached — not used punitively.
• Behavioral standards: Expectations around tone, empathy, and ownership during interactions are documented and reinforced.
• Process ownership: Employees know exactly what authority they have to resolve issues without endless escalation.

Pro Tip: When setting expectations:

• Aim for clarity over volume. It's better to have 5 crystal-clear expectations than 15 vague ones.
• Anchor expectations to outcomes, not just activities. E.g., “Empower customers to feel supported and confident” is better than “Respond to 50 tickets per day.”
• Reinforce regularly, not just during onboarding. High-performing teams revisit and refresh expectations often.

Measuring the ROI of Customer Experience Initiatives

Customer experience can no longer live in the “nice to have” category. To earn true executive buy-in, CX leaders must connect service outcomes directly to financial results. Otherwise, CX programs risk being deprioritized when budgets tighten.

Connecting Customer Service to Business Outcomes

Your service team's KPIs shouldn't live in a vacuum. They should map directly to financial drivers like churn reduction, upsells, cost savings, and lifetime value growth.

Research from PwC shows that 73% of customers say a good experience is key to influencing their brand loyalties — and customers are willing to pay up to 16% more for better service.

That loyalty translates into tangible revenue gains. Faster first-contact resolution reduces ticket handling costs. Higher CSAT scores correlate with improved retention and lower acquisition spend. Strong service experiences also drive customer advocacy, lowering marketing costs over time.

The smartest customer service leaders build dashboards that connect service metrics to financial outcomes — showing not just “what’s happening” but how service quality fuels profitability.

Quantitative and Qualitative Metrics That Matter

Proving ROI requires a mix of hard numbers and contextual insights.

Quantitative metrics that leading organizations track include:

• Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)
• First Contact Resolution (FCR)
• Average Handle Time (AHT)
• Customer Retention Rate

Qualitative insights come from analyzing customer verbatims, service recovery stories, and escalation notes. Sentiment analysis tools can also help your teams mine emotional triggers from large volumes of feedback.

The companies that win don't rely on just scores — they interpret the human stories behind the numbers. The strongest CX business cases blend hard KPIs with rich customer narratives to show both financial and experiential ROI.

Overcoming the Challenges of Partner-Delivery CX Models

Scaling customer experience often requires partnerships: outsourcing support, working with resellers, or building franchise networks. But every additional partner introduces CX risk if accountability isn’t built into the system.

Strategies for Shared Accountability in Customer Experience

True partnership in CX starts with shared vision and shared standards.

Leading organizations bake service expectations into contracts, onboarding, and operational scorecards — not as afterthoughts, but as hard business requirements.

For example, leading companies embed customer experience metrics like CSAT and NPS into their service partner agreements, using them as a foundation for quarterly business reviews and ongoing vendor accountability.

Co-creating service standards from day one — and aligning incentives to CX outcomes — turns vendors into genuine brand stewards. Some companies also run joint customer journey mapping workshops with partners to spot friction points before they damage loyalty.

Shared dashboards tracking both operational KPIs and experiential metrics (like effort scores) are essential. Transparency and accountability make customer service partnerships scalable and sustainable.

Ensuring Consistent Service Quality Across Touchpoints

Consistency across multiple partners and delivery models doesn’t happen organically — it has to be engineered. Research from McKinsey shows that companies delivering consistent customer journeys can improve customer satisfaction by up to 20% and significantly boost loyalty and revenue.

Top organizations build unified knowledge bases that all internal and external team members can access. They standardize coaching frameworks and QA scorecards, ensuring that agents — wherever they sit — represent the brand with consistency.

Disney is a prime example of operational excellence in training. Every internal employee — known as a “cast member” — undergoes onboarding through Disney Traditions, where they learn Disney’s history, service standards, and storytelling principles before interacting with guests.

Technology plays a critical role too. Unified CRM systems, integrated ticketing platforms, and shared reporting tools make it possible to maintain one customer view across every partner interaction.

Standardized QA processes don't just reduce variability — they lay the foundation for scalable, predictable, and profitable customer experiences.

What's next?

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest CX insights, how-to guides, strategies, and resources from top experts in the CX field.